Skip to content

Three-Tier Escalation

Each tier adds one hypothesis and one stronger conclusion. The picture below is the single diagram to remember for the whole paper.

The tiers side-by-side

What the three tiers look like on a 1D cross-section

The tier-by-tier comparison

TierAssumption addedStrength of conclusionLean file
T1one boundary fixed pointMoF_08
T2Lipschitz (L,K)neighborhood of slackMoF_11
T3transversality G>(K+1)positive-measure unsafe regionMoF_11

Tier escalation as a dependency graph

This is the actual logical order the Lean proofs follow, inside MoF_11_EpsilonRobust:

  1. From T1: D(z)=z and f(z)=τ.
  2. From the triangle inequality: d(D(x),z)Kd(x,z).
  3. Apply L-Lipschitz of f: |f(D(x))τ|LKd(x,z).
  4. Bound f's growth along the defense's motion by .
  5. Define the steep region as the set where f exceeds the budget cone; show it is open and, under transversality, non-empty.

Next

The Defense Trilemma · mechanically verified in Lean 4 (46 files, ≈360 theorems, 0 sorry).